Skip to main content

Activity 4: Blog Reflection: Analysis and Design

Part 1

What have you learned from analysis?

When I first approached my client about this project, I was very excited and thought I understood what this client was wanting and what she was envisioning.  We had our first meeting and after gathering information, I was left with more questions than answers.  I thought maybe I had not controlled the flow of the first meeting in a way that would have been more beneficial to the both of us.  During my second meeting, my client seemed overwhelmed with the situation.  I left that meeting with a pile of old paper forms and documents and after analyzing the paper content, I was reminded of the black box diagram, where the designer is left to deduce the purpose of the black box by comparing the input (old course documents) with the output (what the instructor needs to happen). 

What are you planning to do with it?

By our third meeting and through back and forth emails, we seemed to be in agreement in the direction and shape this course should be going.  Our learning objectives became clearer and we started working on converting static paper forms into electronic forms.  Because this is an ongoing course, we had to start posting some of the electronic documents in the online course.  Had I not gone through the needs analysis process, I would have been completely lost.
Brainstorming

In order to keep up with this ongoing course, we have to start uploading the forms and video recordings.  We will need to try to keep at least one week ahead of the course content.  We will need to communicate with the students on a weekly basis and remind them of the work to be completed.  I will start looking at the possibility of incorporating actual surveys.

Part 2

How are analysis and design related for you?

Design cannot happen without first doing an analysis of what is needed and why is needed.  One must also analyze how best to design the content/course so that it meets the needs of the students and the instructor.  Once a complete needs analysis is finalized, the design should be easy to develop.  Therefore, design cannot happen without analysis first.

Think about it in the context the articles and chapters we have read thus far. How closely should these two pieces of the model connect?

These two pieces of the model are extremely connected.  It is important to analyze the problem, in order to come up with a solution.  Depending on the analysis findings, an instructional design approach might be better than other alternatives.  The systems approach suggests (Romiszowski, 1981) that in order to “identify the training or educational needs,” one must first define the problem, analyze the needs, and design the instructional methods (p. 18).

How does the Information R/Evolution video affect each of these?

I thought the video was creative and thought the constant movement of the camera for the first minute or so, kind of reflects the way real life is, chaotic and shaky at times.  I also thought how the text content constantly changed from one thing to another reflects the constant changes and adjustments we all have to make as technology changes on us.  I thought the point of the video was very clear, everything is changing.  The idea of the video seemed to have been carefully analyzed and designed with a specific purpose.

References


Rominszowski, Alexander J. (1981).  Designing Instructional Systems.  New York:  Nichols. Chapters 1, 2 and 9.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 12 Blog Reflection

What does it mean to manage/regulate yourself (self-regulate) and others? Self-regulation and self-management are crucial in all aspects of our lives.  It is even more important when taking online courses and working full-time.  Is vital to managing one’s time so that at the end of the day, all things that needed to be taken care of are crossed out the to-do list, to stay on track.  This is even more important with courses in which there are no hard deadlines, such as this course.  It is so easy to go off track or put things off and before you know it, you find yourself trying to catch up.  When working with clients, like we did for these two big projects, it is also important to manage not only our time with our clients but also regulate our communication and interaction so that the project stays on track.  Having said that, instructional designers need to be flexible enough to accommodate all kind of clients’ personalities and schedules.  Ho...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 16 - Project B Reflection

Reflect on the outcome of Project B. What worked? What did not? Why? Did you use your peer for feedback? If so, discuss the feedback your peer provided; if not, explain why? Discuss your clients feedback? What did you use? What did you reject? Why? I enjoyed working on project B.  I had originally contacted Dr. Taylor for a project he had in mind but he couldn’t meet with me early enough for me to develop his project so I contacted Dr. Holyfield who was in need of finding an electronic option for a portfolio all dental students are to keep for the four years they are dental students.  The reason for the portfolio is that the dental school gets accredited every seven years.  Part of the accreditation process requires the school provides the committee examples of works in which students have been introduced to some specific standards.  In the past, students were keeping a binder with paper copies of specific assignments. Due to having 400+ students and only one facu...
Post a Comment
Read more

Two Examples of Instructional Design

For week 1 of our blog reflection, we were to go out into the world (e.g. grocery store, mall, etc.) and locate two examples of instructional design in which I, as a viewer/reader, was expected to learn something. Then I was to decide the goals of the instruction, how effective it was, and three things I learned.  The first instructional design example is of Scrubbing Bubbles.  While grocery shopping, I was in the cleaning aisle and it dawned on me that most of the cleaning supplies have instructions.  The goal of this content is to teach the user how to properly use this product in order to keep their toilets clean and stain free.  The instruction set comes with illustrated instructions and written instructions.  The illustrated instructions are that of three simple images that the user can easily look at and understand how to use this product.  The written instructions are simple, very well organized, and to the point. The second instructional ...
Post a Comment
Read more